The Myth Makers & The God Makers

This past year, I've discovered Facebook. It is amazing. It is far superior to MySpace on many levels. Like many new media, it is dominated (right now) by younger adults. There is a small debate going on in the "Community of Christ is NOT Mormon's" group. (Yes, the name has problems).

I respond to a young LDS woman who asserts that Mormons are indeed Christian, but they are also the one true church.

Taryn, you are passionate about your faith. That is admirable. I wish more people felt as strongly as you do.

You aren't being vindictive. Are you "slamming" my church? I don't know, but you are essentially saying my church is in apostasy and the only true church is yours.

I understand where you are coming from. I use to believe that about your church too. Yet God keep revealing to me more truth and and I found God's Spirit of Grace alive in other churches and with other people.

I am in the Community of Christ today because it does not discount the experiences of other Christians as naive or incomplete.

Both the Book of Mormon & the Book of Revelation say in the end there will be 2 churches. I believe that. I also don't believe it is one the institutional churches that exist today.

Joseph Smith was a true prophet, but Joseph Smith was wrong too. I think if you can understand the truth in that, you can begin to understand why I am a member of the Community of Christ.

The paradox of faith. Jesus is fully human and fully divine. Joseph Smith is a true prophet and a false prophet. God is three persons, yet truly one one.

I believe in the holy catholic and apostolic Church. (My mom hates this line in the creed because she was taught that the Roman Catholic church was going to be one of the two churches in the end. She was taught it was going to be the Great and Abominable Church of the Devil.")

While writing this entry, I found an article online by Stephen E. Robinson, on Nephi's "Great and Abominable Church." Robinson asserts that:

Once we understand that the term great and abominable church has two uses, the one open (inclusive and archetypal), the other closed (exclusive and historical)

I need to read the whole essay more carefully, but on this point, Robinson nails it. There are dual meanings to this phrase, both a symbolic reading and a literal reading. (I've known that Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell are key to understanding the Book of Mormon and the Book of Revelation.)

Hugh Nibley, a great LDS apologist wrote a book "The Myth Makers" to defend the church from fundamentalist Christian attacks. The of those anti-LDS attacks was called "The God Makers." (a book and a movie). What is ironic is that from a archetypal perspective, both titles accurately describe the church and the church's attackers. (And yes, I'm not being specific about the church, because that is my point.)

Every church has myth makers and god makers. Every religion has myth makers and god makers. So does every movement against a church or religion or a people.

The challenge for us is to discover the true myths which reveal the nature of the true God.

Cool, Hot & Lukewarm or 3Way Forced Choice

When I was a youth minister, one of my favorite games was "Forced Choice" you would pick 2 things and make the players pick one or the other.

You start with something "easy" like Coke or Pepsi (our culture has conditioned people to make that choice). And then you make people defend their choices.

Eventually you work on harder questions like "Democrat" or "Republican"; or "Pro-choice" or "Pro-life". Or "Jesus" or "God".

The questions you struggle with are the ones that are at your growing edge.

But, what if, "there's more than 1 answer to these questions pointing me in a crooked line?" (to quote the latter day psalmists, the Indigo Girls).

On 30 Rock this past year, they played a similar game: Marry, Screw or Kill. You had to name 3 people and were forced to assign them to one of the categories. (This was network TV, so you can imagine that screw might have another word attached to you).

Well, I love the game Marry, Screw or Kill. Yet I decided that Marry wasn't the right word. Vouch is a better word. And you can change the ratings dial to G on the game and get:
Vouch, Kiss or Slap; or
Trust, Eros or Anger/Violence

It is about root emotions. It is my argument that we have the capacity for all 3 of these things.

It defines us as human beings and it is about the choices that we make!

A new friend of mine has been explaining the concept of "Hotness' to me. To her, hot is totally about physical beauty, or the ideal about physical beauty (think Plato). Being a woman raised in our culture, she of course does not think she is hot. (I mean, who does?) Yet I remember a book I read in seminary, God Images and Self-Esteem. It was a feminist critique of the male images that we give to God and how that get internalized into girls and women.

Of course, hot is a metaphor. Our actual temperature does not vary much beyond 98.6 degrees. Yet we are so sure about "hotness" or the favorite metaphor from my day, "cool". So, my new variation on the 3-way-forced choice is:
Hot, Cool or Lukewarm

See, it moves us beyond these unhealthy dualism's. It is the Third Choice. And in that regard, I am a Trinitarian. I love the power of the Third.

And yes, Trinity from the Matrix is Hot. Way Hot!

My Wish for Father's Day (Hughs Family Blog)

From the preamble of Hughs Family Blog:

I want to leave this digital blog to my children, so that as they age they can read about some of the things that saddened our family and brought us great joy. I want them to see how one man has changed their fathers life. I want them to know that person and walk with him as they get older. That is the purpose of this blog.

Bob Hughs a good man. Which of course is an oxymoron. (No, I'm not going to do a cheap joke against Bob). For you see, there is no such thing as a good man. I know this is true because the Bible told me so.

Why do you call me good? No one is good—except God alone. (Luke 18:19, NIV, emphasis added).

You know that verse in the Bible? Yeah, its true. I know it is true. I can vouch for it.

See, I probably should say that I can vouch for Bob Hughes. I know that he a man of God and that he is in the pursuit of being a good man. Has he ever fallen? Please, no rhetorical questions!

Yet Bob Hughes ministered to me yesterday. He came and visited me and we had dinner and we walked and hear Paula sing at the coffee shop.

Bob ministered to me.
Bob walked with me.
Bob was by my side in the midst of myChaos.

But who the heck is Bob?

Bob is the guy that walked with Todd yesterday. Bob went with me to Lincoln to hear Bono talk about DATA (which isn't the real reason we went to Lincoln). Bob and Jennifer were married at the ALC in St. Joseph when I lived there and I was blessed enough to do their wedding.

Yesterday, Bob ministered to me. Bob's presence blessed me. And I thank God for Bob. I truly do.

This is my testimony.

This I believe . . .

I believe in The Church. Not the community, nor even the Christ that the church proclaims, but I believe in The Church. Because it is the one thing in my short, 37 year-old life that I've found I could always depend on.

Yes, I a believer. I am a true believer. Which I thought was my downfall, but is actually my salvation.

I believe in The Church, the living body of Christ.

For The Church is a great repository of spiritual knowledge and wisdom. The problem for too many in the church is they seek easy answers, or simply "best-selling" spirituality. When that happens, the church is cheapened. Yet The Church endures.

The church endures with its vast library and archives of wisdom and knowledge. The church, at its best, is a teacher of alternative wisdom. (God knows the church often fails to live up to its best).

There is an old saying that the purpose of the church is to comfort the afflicted and to afflict the comfortable. Yet the challenge in our current culture is that many of us are both comfortable and afflicted.

We all stand in need of God's grace and God's challenge to live a fuller or an abundant life.

I know that I need God's grace. For with her Grace, I have have the courage to move on.

The Secret . . . Depends if you are in CST or MST

What is the secret?

Is the secret knowledge (gnosis)? Or is the secret framing? Or is it marketing? Or power analysis? Or Praxis?

Yes, praxis. Action and reflection. Action and reflection. (Rinse, lather and repeating.)
Yet I had the chance when I was looking at seminaries to sit in a lecture by Susan Brooks Thistlewait when she was "just" a professor at Chicago Theological Seminary.

She had the answer. (At least for me). And perhaps because she gave me the answer, I didn't need to go to CTS (or so I thought).

She taught me the importance of who asks the 1st question. In one lecture, she had transcended everything that I had learned as a philosophy/religion major at Graceland. She explained that for classical "Western" theology, the 1st question was, "Is there a God?" Yet for "liberation" theologians, the question is, "Is God on our side?"
A powerful difference. A huge difference. Both questions are fine questions, yet one is more powerful than the other.

What question do you find most interesting? That is the question that has more power for you.

It is your true question (or perhaps a truer question).

Dr. Thistlewait is now president of that fine seminary. Yet, why didn't I choose CTS and instead I went to the Iliff School of Theology? I mean, CTS offered me more money than Iliff.

It is a complicated answer. One, I'm not sure I've completely figured out yet. Yet, I think this is true:

I had already been to Chicago.
It was about a girl.
And it was about the girl.
And a boy from the
northwestern district
of Michigan &
the field of dreams,
yearned for the mountains
& a place to call home.

This is my testimony and my story and my song, for today at least.

Upgrades vs. Transformation

I believe it was Henry Weinman that said, "God is that which transforms us in ways that we cannot transform ourselves."

Too often the church, however, has acted like we can indeed transform ourselves. Yet Transformation is an activity of the Spirit. It sometimes happens in unexpected ways and in ways that we can't understand and from the least likely of places.

Upgrades we can do. Incremental changes, we can do. Yet if we are not careful, our attempts to upgrade ourselves can make us regress.

I think I belong to the Regressive Church of Jesus Christ of former latter day saints. Or at least that is part of who we are.

Ronald Regan asked the question in 1980, "Are you better off now than you were 4 years ago?" He framed the debate and won the election. Yet I yearn for a 2nd term for Jimmy Carter. Things would have been better, right?

The year 1980 was the RLDS Church's 150th Anniversary. We were a better church then. No women in the priesthood, that was bad. Yet we were a healthier church in many waves. The body was healthier.
There were women and men who courageously opposed calling women into the priesthood, not because they were anti-woman, but because they were anti-hierarchy. Those brave women and men were right.

I believe in the priesthood of all believers. The true priesthood system of the 1st Century church. All are called. All can be ministers. All can be priesthood. All might be saints.

The Anabaptists were right, but they were martyred for their beliefs.

Priesthood cannot simply be reformed, it must be transformed.

Simple & Wise

A wise seer wrote me that "simple & wise" was her mantra.

The words seems like cool waves running over me. Simple and wise.

Complicated and Technical. I think that has been too often my mantra. Yet I found when I crashed, my technology crashed and I was lost.

GPS is kick-ass, but only if you have power and a good map. A compass that can help almost all the time. A rod of iron, amazingly helpful.

Does anyone know where to find a good ebay deal on a Liahona?

Seperation, Transformation & Return

Sharon Parks in Critical Years, talks about the Shipwrecks of ones life.

Sometimes the shipwreck is like the Minnow and other times its like the Titanic.

Bob Denver made a pretty awesome career about playing a slapstick castaway. And he is forever an icon in popular culture. Plus, he is the guy that could have hooked up with Ginger or Mary Ann, but resisted. That is frickin' courage. He should be a hero to those of us in recovery just on that basis alone.

Please don't think that Gilligan's Island is my favorite TV Show. Hardly. But you can't understand Survivor (or any of the ripoffs) without first knowing about the Black & White version of Gilligan's Island. I didn't read this somewhere (or maybe I did at TVBarn), but I know it. I know it is true, because I lived it.

Culture is what is missing from the Wesleyan Quadrilateral. The extreme challenge to the church is how, not to tell stories. But to the root metaphors of THE Story. Joseph Campbell helped popularize the works of Carl Jung on this issue.

There is a collective unconscious. I don't know if that reflects the mind of God, or reflects the culture. Whatever the case, there is A story. A cingular, I mean singular story. I can sing about it (decently), or play an instrument (worse) or blog about (hopefully better than average).

A C+ in the Kingdom. Better than average. Yeah, that is a freakin' life. But God doesn't call us to be average or even specialists. He calls us to into being and sends us into mission. (I know this to be true because Commission magazine told me so, in 1979).

Reorganize, Redesign, Redeploy

Why not rekindle, renew & relive?

The 3 R's are important. But who will pick a trinity?

The Senior High Campers of Section 156

There is not a single appointee in the Community of Christ who is in their 30's who is "called" to minister in the United States or Canada.

Art Smith, was the youngest appointee at 1-time (he took the title away from me). Yet Art made his career in Canada, then Tahiti, now "South America."

For some strange reason, almost all the men I admire that still work for the church are involved in International (or cross-cultural) ministries.

Yet cross-cultural ministries is the hallmark of 21st Century church, regardless of your turf. I have seen Steve Shields as a "young" missionary in the Jungles of the 90210. Art learned to love K-State football in Manhatten (little apple, not Big Apple).

Gary. Gary Logan is perhaps one of the greatest builders of his generation in the Church. The man taught me about partnerships. He dreamed of a church and the YMCA sharing common turf. Yet he has been pushed aside by those with smaller dreams.

Yet the current hierarchy only seems to value these gifts "overseas." But when you grow up in Michigan, you know that one man's lake is another woman's ocean.

Perhaps that is why Park of the Pines was so special. Kids from across "the locks" interacted with their Michigan RLDS sisters and brothers.

Art, Jeff, Charmaine & Tony, Dan & Deb, Steve(s), Aimee & Val & their dad, and the current Bishop of Canada (my Jr. High Camp director) all know that Park of the Pines is a true campgrounds of Zion. (or is it reuniongrounds?)

edited and expanded on May 19th, 2007

Second Acts

At the end of the month I will conclude my almost 15 year career as a professional minister with the Community of Christ. My denomination is in the midst of a corporate downsizing, where over 20% of the worldwide staff have been terminated (or given involuntary or voluntary separation, that is the corporate word for it). It isn't a huge story to the outside world (the KC Star ran a short article), but it is huge within our faith community.

There are those that believe it is one more sign of pending collapse of the organization. There are also those that believe it is amazing opportunity to rethink how the church works. Neither statement is true, but I do believe that if the church (at least at the headquarters level) is to transform its self, it must be willing to engage in some more soul searching and honestly explore dysfunction in our corporate culture.

Right now, I'm hurt, dismayed, baffled and yet somehow hopeful. I think I will end up in a better place in six months than where I am right now. Yet how many of us jump at the opportunity for for extreme personal growth, if we must first endure months of significant pain and turmoil?

I've resisted the urge to blog about this process (for a wide range of issues), but I feel I need to start
Cross posted at ToddElkins.net

Welcome to Leaves . . .

While in college I read a wonderful book by Reinhold Niebuhr, Leaves from the Notebook of a Tamed Cynic. It is excerpts from the journal of Neibuhr as he served as a young parish pastor in Detroit at Bethel Evangelical Church.

Reinhold Neibuhr is perhaps the greatest American theologian of the 20th Century. In the journal he is brilliant and the proto-outline of his eventual theological themes are present, but the uncertainty and vulnerability of a young man searching to live our his call and vocation are very much present.

I thought it would be a fitting tribute to Neibuhr (ok, perhaps not fitting, he deserves sooo much more!) to name this blog after him.

In this blog I hope to reflect more theologically on the state of the church in general and given specific attention to my current fellowship, the Community of Christ (formerly the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints).

I do also blog at another place, ToddElkins.Net, yet I'm going to try a different style of blogging than has been present there. Perhaps I'm kidding myself that anyone is actually interested in reading either of my blogs, but really this blog is more about capturing a wide range of thoughts I have right now than actually being worried if anyone is reading. (However, if you are reading, please send me an e-mail or post a comment!).